Their are a lot of definitions of privacy. Freedom from the state of being observed. Being apart from other people. Solitude. The state of being concealed. Secrecy. How does this multi-dimensional word fit into a marriage that has lost it’s footing through a series of lies and deceits? Maybe it doesn’t.
I ate 2 chocolate bars yesterday. This is my right. This has no bearing on my husband. It’s not a great nutritional decision but I don’t have compromised health so it won’t affect my life, nor my husbands. I find it somewhat embarrassing that I couldn’t control my desires. I couldn’t stop at one…or bet yet at one half. I devoured two. It is no one’s business but my own. I struggled with an eating disorder in college so I find the fact that I lost control to be rather shameful. Yet, told my husband.
The reason why I told him is simply because we are practicing what it feels like to have complete transparency in our relationship. It’s not always easy to do, and truth be told it took me 24 hours to tell him what I had done with the chocolate bars. But I did it – and it felt good. Of course, chocolate is the easy part.
After our infidelities, both my husband and I needed to come clean to one another about our betrayals of each other. In the presence of my amazing therapist, we told one another all of our secrets. This was one of the hardest exercises we have ever done. My husband went so far as to take a lie detector (his idea) so I could be confident there were no other secrets. Even one morsel of a lie is a foundation for another. Once we came clean, we truly don’t want to dirty ourselves again. It’s like a shiny new car – the first speck of dirt is noticed and examined and wiped away quickly. But once you let it go, you barely notice when it’s become weeks since it’s been washed. My husband and I are hyper vigilant to keep that first speck of dirt from landing on our marriage.
Is this the right path for everyone? Honestly, I don’t know why it’s not. What is the point of keeping a secret from the person you love most in the world. How does that honor him/her? How does that show respect for their ability to be empathetic? I argue that it doesn’t. For a relationship to be truly honored, it needs to be free of lies and the pain that comes with them.
There is, of course, a flip side. There are rules. 1. Each partner needs to willingly give the other space. There is no benefit to listening to every call, reading every email and otherwise controlling all of their communication. Maybe in the immediate aftermath of an affair discovery this would be the case – but that needs to be eliminated or reduced as quickly as possible. If it’s not, the betrayed will become obsessive and this will hurt them. 2. If the spouse judges everything that they are told – this is also disrespectful and won’t further the relationship. This will make the person who is trying to share want to revert back into their shell of secrecy. If you are being respected with the truth, then you need to be mature enough to handle it. 3. Don’t ask if you don’t want to know. This isn’t an exercise for those who aren’t committed to rebuilding a healthy, happy marriage. It’s not a way to get ammunition to use against them. 4. This is a two way street. You can’t expect honesty if you aren’t willing to give it back. What did you do this week that you didn’t share with your mate? Did you say something disrespectful about them to someone they know? Did you act inappropriately in any manner? Did you eat 2 chocolate bars and hide the wrappers?
Once the one who was hurt by a secret or a lie learns that they have access, when needed, to any information they require – then hopefully they can become less concerned with it. Once this fight for knowledge is put to rest – a more open, loving, intimate, equal relationship can start to grow again. More importantly, once they witness their spouse telling them their inner most truths – then, and only then, can trust begin to reemerge.